Posts Tagged ‘Holger Badstuber’

Bayern Munich may have the best left-footed defender in Germany, but did they let the best overall slip through their fingers?

Mats Hummels progressed through the ranks at Bayern, a year or two ahead of Holger Badstuber, and played for their string between 2005 and 2007.

He flirted briefly with the Bayern first team, but ultimately found chances were few and far between. Highly thought of, he was sent on loan to Borussia Dortmund to gain experience.

Whilst undoubtedly talented, I don’t think anyone quite expected him to make such an impact as he did at Westfalenstadion.

Hummels and Subotic: works even when wet.

He was in the first team immediately, forming a formidable partnership in the centre of defence alongside Nevan Subotic. Together the pair became one of the best in the Bundesliga.

His move was made permanent in the winter transfer window of 2009, a year after his arrival. Bayern, they stated, were happy with his development, but were happier with the centre back’s they had: Lucio, Martin Demichelis, Daniel van Buyten and Breno. A decision they may now regret.

In the 2008/09 season, his first full season with the club, Dortmund had the second best defence in the league. But for Hummels and Die Schwarzgelben, the best was yet to come.

That best was last season, when Hummels helped Dortmund to a first league title in almost a decade. He may not have grabbed the headlines like Gotze, Sahin et al, but his contribution should not be underestimated.

He’s slowly but surely adding to his reputation and his caps at international level, and with Per Mertesacker’s form hardly inspiring, he should find himself firmly in the side come Euro 2012. His star his already rising fast, and Euro 2012 could be the tournament that catapults him to superstardom.

“He’s the most complete centre back in the world: his man-marking and passing abilities are absolutely world class. I’ve seen him mark some of football’s best strikers into anonymity for 90 minutes, but he still needs to improve: those times when he doesn’t succeed for 90 minutes it’s typically 89 minutes and 50 seconds, with the last 10 being just enough time for things to fall apart.” – Clark Whitney, German football editor. @Mr_Bundesliga.

“Mats Hummels, 23, for me, is the best young central defender in the world and one of the very best period.” Gerry Wittmann, of Bundesliga fanatic. @Bundesliga4u

The video below features Hummels displaying some of the passing skills mentioned above:


Germany currently has an embarrassment of riches when it comes to up-and-coming young stars. Thomas Muller, for example, is only 22 – but you’d be forgiven for thinking he was older, such were his performances at the 2010 World Cup. Holger Badstuber, Mats Hummels, Marco Reus and the Bender twins – all just 22. Mesut Ozil is practically a veteran at 23 years old.

So, out of those aged 21 and younger, who is the best? I have deliberately left the name Mario Gotze off this list, as I’ve no doubt he’d come top. So perhaps I should ask, out of those aged 21 and under, whose number isn’t Mario Gotze, who is the best young German prospect?

Please vote in this poll to decide. I’ve put a few names down, but I want as many opinions as possible, so feel free to use the ‘other’ box if I’ve missed out someone you feel is worthy. Thanks.